Puerto Rico or Aruba: Which Caribbean Paradise Should be Your Next Vacation Destination?

By Steve Dez •  Updated: 12/31/23 •  10 min read

Here’s a Youtube Video about Puerto Rico or Aruba


Whether you’re yearning for the lush landscapes of Puerto Rico or the tranquil beaches of Aruba, both island destinations hold a wealth of natural beauty and recreational activities to explore.

From the rich Spanish heritage seen in Puerto Rico’s architecture and cuisine, to Aruba’s evident Dutch influence – both offer an immersion into unique local cultures.

The size difference between Puerto Rico and Aruba leads to distinct geographical landscapes, with Puerto Rico boasting verdant rainforests and Aruba known for its sandy shores.

When it comes to safety, both destinations offer relatively safe environments for tourists, but each presents different considerations.

If budgeting is your concern, we’ll delve into a cost comparison of vacationing in either location.

Finally, we’ll present an economic overview of both islands, highlighting their GDP per capita differences. Bear in mind that each destination offers unique experiences that transcend their economic indicators.

puerto rico or aruba
Courtesy of @turisteandoenpr
Best for Finding Cheap Flights!
Skiplagged - Travel Tickets on Discount!

Hey there! Are you looking for a way to save money on your next flight?

Skiplagged is a travel search engine that helps users find hidden-city flights, which can be a great way to save money on your ticket.

Give it a try and see how much you can save!

We earn a commission if you make a purchase, at no additional cost to you.

Exploring the Natural Beauty and Recreation in Puerto Rico and Aruba

In any case, if you’re a lover of breathtaking Caribbean islands, then both Puerto Rico, known as Borinquen Island, and Aruba will offer you a spectacle of nature’s paradise.

Now that I think about it, Aruba, this small island just north of Venezuela, is a jewel in the Caribbean Sea with pristine beaches like Palm Beach and Baby Beach. It’s perfect for relaxing or engaging in water activities such as kite surfing. You see, despite its small size—only about 180 square kilometers—Aruba offers an abundance of beach time to visitors.

By the way, when it comes to Puerto Rico on the other hand—which is comparatively much larger with coastlines spanning over 200 miles—it provides abundant natural beauty beyond its stunning beaches. In fact, from hiking trails in the El Yunque rainforest to exploring Old San Juan, there are numerous options for adventure seekers looking for tropical vacations.

Immersing in Local Culture: Spanish Influence in Puerto Rico vs Dutch Influence in Aruba

You see, part of what makes travel exciting is immersing oneself into local cultures and traditions. Notably so are the differences between Dutch-influenced Aruba and Spanish-influenced Puerto Rico. As I’m sure you’d agree – both offer unique experiences but present different cultural nuances.

Aruban cuisine,, influenced by its Dutch colonizers serves seafood predominantly along with other local indigenous foods – goat meat being one! Not to forget their famous pastechis – stuffed pastry snacks- an absolute must try!

On the other hand, Puerto Rico, known for its rich history and Spanish influence carries with it a flavor-packed cuisine which is a fusion of Spanish, African and Taino influences. Some staples include mofongo, pastelón and arroz con gandules – all worth indulging when on Caribbean cruises.

Analyzing the Geographical Differences: Size Matters in Puerto Rico and Aruba

Aruba is one of the smallest islands in the Caribbean while Puerto Rico’s land mass definitely towers over. The smaller size of Aruba could be an advantage as it allows you to explore more without having to travel long distances.

On the contrary, Puerto Rico’s larger size not only comes with diverse landscapes but also experiences – from mountains to coastlines stretching over 200 miles.

Safety Considerations when Traveling to Puerto Rico vs Aruba

All things considered,, safety becomes an important aspect any traveler would look at when selecting a destination.

While petty crime issues prevail in certain parts of Puerto Rico; if safety is your non-negotiable then Aruba tourism might put your mind at ease as it has been described as safer overall.

Cost Comparison: Vacationing in Puerto Rico vs Aruba

When planning for tropical vacations, we cannot avoid discussing cost differences.

You see, cheaper flights from mainland U.S., lower food costs make holidaying in Puerto Rico tourism more budget friendly than its counterpart—Aruba.

Economic Overview of Puerto Rico and Aruba: GDP Per Capita Differences

From an economy standpoint—as of 2017 Aruba’s GDP per capita was $38,442 whereas in 2020, it was $33,400 for Puerto Rico, showing some difference in prosperity between the two Caribbean islands.

This however should not heavily alter your travel plans as both continue to thrive as popular travel destinations.

In essence- whether your heart is set on unwinding at peaceful beaches, embracing the vibrant nightlife or tantalizing your taste buds with local foods – Both Aruba and Puerto Rico can provide unforgettable Caribbean vacations.

The ultimate travel booking experience
Agoda - Find your perfect stay

Hey there! Are you planning a trip and looking for a great place to stay?

Agoda.com is an online travel booking platform that offers a wide range of accommodation options including hotels, resorts, and vacation rentals at great prices.

It's a one-stop-shop for all your travel needs!

We earn a commission if you make a purchase, at no additional cost to you.

puerto rico or aruba


If you’re planning your next vacation and cannot decide between Puerto Rico or Aruba, this site is perfect to get detailed information about both destinations. Get insight on the distinct culture, stunning beaches, local cuisines and much more.

Among the numerous interesting facts about Puerto Rico, it is particularly intriguing to understand how similar Puerto Rico is to the US. Despite its geographical separation, Puerto Rico has many similarities with the US due to its historical and political associations.

In addition, if you’re a beach enthusiast looking for your next sun-soaked holiday destination, Puerto Rico could be an ideal choice. Read up on some of the best and most beautiful beaches in Puerto Rico by visiting our page on the top beaches in Puerto Rico.

Lastly, understanding travel costs can play a significant role when planning a trip. Our post discussing the cost of spending a week in Puerto Rico will give you a clear idea about your budget needs for accommodation, food, transportation and sightseeing during your stay.

My Personal Take about Puerto Rico or Aruba

Puerto Rico or Aruba: It’s the title of my latest blog post, a question that might be playing on your mind as you plan your dream Caribbean getaway.

Now that I think about it, each island has its unique charm but as a seasoned Puerto Rico traveler, there is an alluring blend of vibrant culture, mesmerizing landscapes and warm hospitality that makes Puerto Rico really stand out.

In any case,

This richness in experience tilts the balance in favor of Puerto Rico and fills me with nothing but optimism for every visitor soon landing here.

Smart phone plan for smart people
Google Fi - Simplify your phone plan

Hey there! Are you tired of dealing with complicated phone plans?

Google Fi is a phone plan service by Google that offers flexible and affordable options, with no hidden fees or contracts.

It's a great way to save money and simplify your phone plan.

We earn a commission if you make a purchase, at no additional cost to you.

Frequently Asked Questions about Puerto Rico or Aruba

Experience the true local living
Vrbo - Find your home away from home!

Hey there! Are you looking for a more authentic and comfortable travel experience?

Vrbo is a vacation rental platform that offers a wide variety of properties, including apartments, houses, and villas for rent by owner.

It's a great way to experience the local living and feel like a true resident of the place you're visiting.

We earn a commission if you make a purchase, at no additional cost to you.

Before you go…

Takeaway 1: Unique Experiences

Aruba and Puerto Rico both offer unique experiences for travelers. Aruba, with its beautiful beaches and Dutch influence, is perfect for a family trip. The small island allows for more beach time, with a land area of roughly 180 square kilometers. On the other hand, Puerto Rico boasts mountains, coastlines stretching over 200 miles, and a rich Spanish influence. It offers more than just beaches, with artisans and crafts centers where local artists create sculptures, historical sites to explore, hiking trails in El Yunque Forest, and vibrant nightlife options.

Takeaway 2: Size and Safety

One major difference between the two islands is their size. Puerto Rico is much bigger than Aruba. Additionally, safety can be an issue in certain parts of Puerto Rico due to petty crime problems; however, Aruba has been described as safer.

Takeaway 3: Affordability

When it comes to affordability factors, Puerto Rico might be cheaper in terms of flights being shorter from mainland U.S., dining costs also being lower compared to Aruba.

The economy-difference between the two islands signifies that as of 2017, Aruba’s GDP per capita was $38,442, whereas in 2020, it was $33,400 for Puerto Rico. Ultimately, both destinations can provide unforgettable Caribbean vacations depending on what you look forward to on your trip.. Whether you’re seeking rich culture, unwinding at peaceful beaches,enjoying vibrant nightlife or trying out local foods; both Aruba and Puerto Rico have something unique to offer.
<br

Wondering when is the best time to go to Puerto Rico? Click the link to find out more.

Best Place for Hotel Bookings
Booking.com - Where every stay is a great stay.

Hey there! Are you looking for an easy and convenient way to book your next hotel stay?

Booking.com is an online hotel and lodging reservation service that offers a wide range of accommodation options at great prices, and with an easy and fast booking process.

Give it a try and see how easy it is to plan your next trip!

We earn a commission if you make a purchase, at no additional cost to you.

Steve Dez

Also known as Richport, is a Puerto Rican creator and writer. He grew up in the island and always had a passion for writing, he wrote his first play at the age of 12 and has been creating content ever since. He's now a well-known blogger and creative who writes posts, songs and poetry that showcase his love for his roots, blending traditional stories with modern themes always with some adobo and boricua flavors in the mix.