Is Puerto Rico Outside the US: Understanding its Unique Status and Relationship with America

By Steve Dez •  Updated: 12/30/23 •  12 min read

Here’s a Youtube Video about Is Puerto Rico outside the US.


Although many often ask, “Is Puerto Rico outside the US?”, the answer is much more complex. Despite not being a state, Puerto Rico is an unincorporated territory of the United States, a status defined by a series of court cases known as the Insular Cases.

This unique political position impacts everything from Puerto Rican citizenship—which is closely intertwined with U.S. citizenship—to the freedom of movement for Puerto Ricans who possess residence rights across all 50 states.

Additionally, the island’s separate tax laws and travel regulations distinguish it from mainstream U.S., culminating in an ongoing debate over whether Puerto Rico should remain a commonwealth, become a state or seek independence.

is puerto rico outside the us
Courtesy of @whateverpuertorico
Best for Finding Cheap Flights!
Skiplagged - Travel Tickets on Discount!

Hey there! Are you looking for a way to save money on your next flight?

Skiplagged is a travel search engine that helps users find hidden-city flights, which can be a great way to save money on your ticket.

Give it a try and see how much you can save!

We earn a commission if you make a purchase, at no additional cost to you.

Understanding the Status of Puerto Rico as an Unincorporated Territory of the United States

You see, Puerto Rico is indeed outside the US, in a nuanced sort of way. It’s officially an unincorporated territory of the United States but not a fully incorporated state. Now that I think about it, you could say it’s both part and not part of America in different respects. So, is Puerto Rico a state? Well, no. But let me clarify that further.

Puerto Rico’s intricacies lie in its classification as an “unincorporated territory,” meaning that while it is controlled by the U.S government, it remains separate from the mainland. This complex status stems from what’s known as “the Insular Cases,” which dictate Puerto Rico as a territory “belonging to, but not a part of” America.

Insights into the Insular Cases and How They Define Puerto Rico\’s Relationship with America

In any case, if we delve deeper into the Insular Cases, they illuminate our understanding about Puerto Rico US relationship. These rulings established that full constitutional rights do not automatically extend to all territories under U.S jurisdiction over Puerto Rico or elsewhere unless Congress explicitly bestows them.

All things considered, this set of Supreme Court rulings has shaped Puerto Rico’s existence under American governance and further underscores its unique association with America without being entirely integrated.

Puerto Rican Citizenship and Its Connection to US Citizenship

You might wonder – does being born in Puerto result in automatic American citizenship? The answer is yes…and no. Here’s why: while Puerto Ricans have been granted U.S citizenship since 1917 (a key milestone in US and Puerto Rico history), they are considered citizens born outside of U.S states in certain legal contexts.

Puerto Rican citizenship does not exist independently from United States citizenship. However, it’s important to know that this doesn’t make Puerto Ricans any less American; it’s simply a caveat born from the territory’s unique status.

Freedom of Movement for Puerto Ricans: A Look at Residence Rights Across All 50 States

By the way, let’s talk about one of the pivotal Rights of Puerto Ricans: freedom of movement. They can freely move throughout all 50 states, just like any other American citizen. No special permits or permissions needed. So while there may be anomalies in their political status, when it comes to everyday mobility and residence rights, they enjoy equal privileges as their mainland counterparts.

How Tax Laws and Travel Regulations Separate Puerto Rico from Mainstream U.S.

To lend perspective on how Puerto Rico is treated differently in some aspects – consider tax laws and travel regulations. Yes, for instance, under Internal Revenue Code (IRC) §933, income generated within Puerto Rico is excluded from U.S federal tax for bona fide residents of the island. Now isn’t that something?

In essence, when it comes to such laws and regulations even though being a Puerto Rico US territory,, its treatment mirrors that typically accorded to foreign countries!

Exploring the Debate over Puerto Rico’s Status: From Commonwealth to Statehood or Independence

The Status of Puerto Rico, whether it may become a fully-fledged state or gain independence as a separate entity often stirs intense debates worldwide. After all, since achieving commonwealth status in 1952, the island has enjoyed partial political self-governance under the guise of the Commonwealth of Puerto Rico.

Many argue that having an American Passport in Puerto Rico and being under full authority of Congress should naturally lead towards statehood. Others champion for a distinct Puerto Rican Independence. The question remains – Is Puerto Rico outside the US or an integral part of it? These debates are a testament to how layered and fascinating Puerto Rico’s standing truly is.

All in all, understanding the relationship between Puerto Rico and America is less like reading a clear-cut rule book and more like interpreting a beautifully complex tapestry of history, politics, law, and culture. So yes, geographically speaking – is puerto rico outside the us? Most certainly yes. Politically? Well…that’s a story still being written.

The ultimate travel booking experience
Agoda - Find your perfect stay

Hey there! Are you planning a trip and looking for a great place to stay?

Agoda.com is an online travel booking platform that offers a wide range of accommodation options including hotels, resorts, and vacation rentals at great prices.

It's a one-stop-shop for all your travel needs!

We earn a commission if you make a purchase, at no additional cost to you.

is puerto rico outside the us


Geographically, Puerto Rico could be seen as outside the US mainland, but it’s actually a U.S. territory. This unique status can lead to confusion about Puerto Rico’s place in the world and its relationship with the U.S., which is further explored on our page “Does Puerto Rico Belong to The US”.

Not only does this relationship affect political and legal matters, but it also impacts travel. Despite its location in the Caribbean Sea, American citizens do not need a passport or visa to visit Puerto Rico – an interesting fact that might surprise you when you read our article on ‘Is Puerto Rico Visa Free’.

During your research about traveling to this beautiful territory, you might wonder: is Puerto Rican cuisine vegetarian-friendly? The answer is yes! Vegetarians can delight in a variety of dishes that are free of meat products. Learn more about this aspect of Puerto Rican culture by taking a look at our blog post titled ‘Is Puerto Rico Vegetarian Friendly’.

Puerto Rico has many spectacular places worth visiting. For first-time travelers or those looking for unique experiences on their return trip, we’ve compiled an amazing list of sites in our feature ‘Puerto Rico Places to Visit – San Juan’, where we delve into the charming spots and breathtaking landscapes offered by San Juan city – certainly a must-go destination!

My Personal Take about Is Puerto Rico outside the US.

Hey there, it’s Steve, your ultimate guide to the beautiful land which lingers between being a part of America and yet so uniquely independent.

I noticed many people still ask ‘is Puerto Rico outside the US‘. Have fascinating chat with friends gain more perspectives backed up solid information right from my experience traveling in this beautiful tropical paradise again and again.

No need to frown anymore if you’ve wondered too. By the way, its uniqueness lies exactly in this blending – Americans don’t need a passport to visit it, but on stepping foot here, you will feel like entering an exciting world beautifully separate from mainland America.

Now that I think about it, what excites travelers is this enchanting melange of cultures- rigidity conveyed by old-styled San Juan streets stitched perfectly alongside famous Bioluminescent bays catering resilience symbols sparkling every night! By no means take these as simple words of advice; rather international flavors lingering over you gently reminding why millions are already queuing up for a trip here.

You see-In any case one can attempt grasping the beauty & mystery surrounding Puerto Rico. Once visited islands elegant broadways mimicking NYC avenue grandiosity bearing plush fiery Latin vibe will leave you mesmerized wanting another spin incessantly!<

 
 
 
 
 
View this post on Instagram
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 

A post shared by PUERTO RICO COMPARTE TU ISLA / AIRBNB / CONTENT CREATOR (@puertoricocompartetuisla)


Smart phone plan for smart people
Google Fi - Simplify your phone plan

Hey there! Are you tired of dealing with complicated phone plans?

Google Fi is a phone plan service by Google that offers flexible and affordable options, with no hidden fees or contracts.

It's a great way to save money and simplify your phone plan.

We earn a commission if you make a purchase, at no additional cost to you.

Frequently Asked Questions about Is Puerto Rico outside the US.

Experience the true local living
Vrbo - Find your home away from home!

Hey there! Are you looking for a more authentic and comfortable travel experience?

Vrbo is a vacation rental platform that offers a wide variety of properties, including apartments, houses, and villas for rent by owner.

It's a great way to experience the local living and feel like a true resident of the place you're visiting.

We earn a commission if you make a purchase, at no additional cost to you.

Before you go…

Takeaway 1: Puerto Rico’s unique political status

Puerto Rico, oh boy, it’s a bit of a political puzzle, you know? Sure, it’s part of the good old U.S. of A, but it ain’t no state. It falls under the category of “unincorporated territory,” which means it’s controlled by Uncle Sam but separated from the mainland. It’s like being in a relationship where you’re kinda together but also kinda not. This peculiar setup is governed by something called “the Insular Cases,” which basically say that Puerto Rico belongs to the United States but isn’t fully part of it. Talk about complicated!

Takeaway 2: The citizenship paradox for Puerto Ricans

Alright folks, here comes another mind-boggler. So, Puerto Ricans were given U.S. citizenship way back in 1917 (woohoo for them!), but here’s the kicker – they’re considered as citizens born outside of U.S states in some legal situations. It’s like being invited to a party but only being allowed to stay on the porch while everyone else dances inside! And guess what? There ain’t no separate Puerto Rican citizenship because our little island isn’t its own independent nation (bummer!). But hey, at least they can pack their bags and explore all 50 states whenever they want.

Takeaway 3: Puerto Rico – a territory with an identity crisis

Puerto Rico, my dear friend, has an identity crisis going on. On one hand, it’s under the full authority of Congress and has this fancy-sounding commonwealth status since 1952 (partial self-governance and all that jazz). But despite these so-called privileges, there are still heated debates about what exactly our status should be. Some folks talk about statehood, while others dream of complete independence. It’s like trying to pick a flavor at the ice cream shop – so many options, so little time! And let’s not forget, in some situations, Puerto Rico is treated like a foreign country when it comes to taxes and travel regulations. Can’t make up its mind, can it? So there you have it, my friends. Puerto Rico – a unique mix of American territory but not quite part of the club. It’s got its own quirks and complexities that keep everyone scratching their heads. But

Discover more about the renowned attractions and specialties of this Caribbean paradise through this useful guide on things Puerto Rico is famous for.

Best Place for Hotel Bookings
Booking.com - Where every stay is a great stay.

Hey there! Are you looking for an easy and convenient way to book your next hotel stay?

Booking.com is an online hotel and lodging reservation service that offers a wide range of accommodation options at great prices, and with an easy and fast booking process.

Give it a try and see how easy it is to plan your next trip!

We earn a commission if you make a purchase, at no additional cost to you.

Steve Dez

Also known as Richport, is a Puerto Rican creator and writer. He grew up in the island and always had a passion for writing, he wrote his first play at the age of 12 and has been creating content ever since. He's now a well-known blogger and creative who writes posts, songs and poetry that showcase his love for his roots, blending traditional stories with modern themes always with some adobo and boricua flavors in the mix.